The EPROPULSION Spirit is a relative newcomer to the UK market, although it has been available elsewhere for about four years now; and we have been using one ourselves since April 2017. It bears some obvious resemblances in terms of specification and even appearance to the market-leading Torqeedo 1003, but also has some significant differences. Most of this page assumes you’re already familiar with the Torqeedo, but if not see: Torqeedo 1003
First the most important differences, good and bad, ePropulsion Spirit to Torqeedo 1003:
– MUCH QUIETER, The Torqeedo is quiet compared to a petrol outboard, but the Epropulsion seems noticeably quieter than the Torqeedo. This is because the Torqeedo has a small, fast-spinning motor driving the propeller through a reduction gearbox, whereas the Epropulsion has a larger, direct-drive motor (no gearbox). The Torqeedo solution is in theory at least electrically more efficient; the Epropulsion mechanically more simple. The loudest part (ie what you hear) of the Torqeedo is that reduction gearbox, and it’s widely described as a “whine”. Though we have not measured it, the ePropulsion seems to be quieter (in dB terms), and what noise you do hear is a deeper “hum”. To our ears at least it’s more pleasant to listen to and generally sounds more “refined” (if there’s any wind or waves, it’s all-but silent). There is a video (not ours) of both here: Torqeedo & ePropulsion sound test
– 4kg HEAVIER. The most comparable Torqeedo 1003C (with 915Wh battery) weighs 14.9kg, the ePropulsion Spirit (1018Wh battery) weighs 18.6kg. The differences are mainly the larger capacity battery, the physically larger motor, and the fact that the eProp’s motor is housed in a metal casing rather than the Torqeedo’s (very solid and never given us any trouble) plastic one.
– FLOATING BATTERY. The E-Propulsion battery is physically larger, partly because it houses a battery with 10% more capacity (1018Wh vs 915Wh for Torqeedo), and partly because it encloses enough air for it to float if accidentally dropped. We have tried it, and it does float. The Torqeedo batteries do not float, nor are they claimed to; we have not tried that ourselves but unfortunately (for them, and their wallets!) some of our customers have… it’s an expensive mistake to make!
– FASTER CHARGE TIME. From flat, with the mains chargers supplied: the Torqeedo 915Wh battery charges in about 10 hours; the Epropulsion 1018Wh in about 5.5hrs. There is also a Fast Charger option on the Epropulsion, which reduces charge time from flat to about 2.5hrs (take it to the pub with you, it will be fully recharged by the time you’ve eaten and had a couple of drinks). Both also have the option of using 12V DC chargers.
The less significant differences:
– The Eprop’s tiller is folding rather than removable, which also means there’s only one cable to connect/disconnect (compared with the Torqeedo’s two cables). But it does mean the dismantled Torqeedo is slightly smaller to store.
– The EProp does not have GPS, so it does not have a readout for speed and range (the Torqeedo does). However both motors do tell you how much battery is left, which seems to be the bit people find most useful on the Torqeedo LCD.
– The EProp has a bit more range. We haven’t done that much in the way of truly fair testing (identical boats, identical conditions, identical battery charge states) but so far there doesn’t seem to be much in it on top speed. That was on a lake, on a small RIB, flat calm. At half power the EProp is possibly slightly faster than the Torqeedo, and (from a customer with a Drascombe Lugger) it looks like the difference might be more in favour of the Eprop on heavier boats. These differences are most likely due to propeller characteristics. If you conclude “there’s really not much difference” then as the Eprop battery also has 10% more capacity than the largest Torqeedo battery, this means the Eprop will take you about 10% further, at the same speed. In more general terms on a typical dinghy both will run for about an hour flat out (at roughly 6 knots, giving a range of approx 6 nautical miles) or two hours at half power (5 knots, 10nm).
– Eprop only has one battery option. The Torqeedo can be purchased with 532 or 915Wh batteries, the EProp only comes with a 1018Wh battery.
– The “Remote” options. (May be significant if you want to use the motor on different boats.) The Torqeedo remote is wired, and interchangeable with the tiller. You buy the tiller version and then add the remote control if you want one. On the Epropulsion the tiller (hard-wired) and remote (wireless) are not interchangeable, you have to choose one or the other when you buy it (and you can’t later use a remote with a tiller model, nor vice versa)..BUT the remote version of the Epropulsion is compatible with standard steering gear, and the Torqeedo isn’t. On both T and E you can lock the steering and use the boat’s rudder, but if you want to steer the Torqeedo directly you have to invent something.
We always get asked “how far will it go?” This is the proverbial piece of string question. It depends how fast you run it, how heavy the boat is, how much tide is running in which direction, the battery charge state, the temperature… and more factors still. So the following is indicative but in no way any kind of guarantee:
– At full power, the two motors are roughly the same in terms of speed (~6 knots on a dinghy) so the range of the Epropulsion is about 10% more than the Torqeedo simply because the battery has more capacity. At full power the Torqeedo will run 55 minutes giving a range of 5.5 miles; the Eprop will run for an hour giving a range of 6 miles.
– At half power you should get more like 10 nautical miles from the Torqeedo. If our finding is correct, that the Eprop is slightly faster at half power than the Torqeedo, then this, combined with the larger battery capacity, would indicate a range of 11-12 nautical miles for the Eprop.
– The range/run-time will increase further as you slow down more, but since 10 nautical miles is already far more than most people ever need from a small outboard motor we haven’t really bothered testing it. Torqeedo claim 35 miles at 2 knots (for their 915Wh battery); we don’t want to sit in a boat going at 2 knots for 17 hours to prove or disprove it!
SHAFT LENGTH – S, L, or XS?
Both the Epropulsion and the Torqeedo spin much larger propellers, more slowly, than comparable petrol outboards. This makes more efficient use of the high torque characteristics of electric motors. BUT a large propeller is only more efficient if it’s actually underwater, and that means the shafts have to be a bit longer. So the “S” shaft electric motors are almost the same length as an “L” shaft petrol motor. However on many small boats these “S” shaft electric outboards stick down rather deeper than necessary – which is inconvenient when coming into a beach or slipway – so Epropulsion now also make an “XS” (Extra Short) model. This is roughly equivalent to a petrol “S” shaft and immerses the propeller deep enough on nearly all the boats we sell including SpearFish, F-RIB, Nautiraid Coracles, Nestaways, DinghyGo. XS is the most suitable length for almost all small inflatable dinghies on the market (up to about 4m long).
The Epropulsion is also a bit cheaper than Torqeedo’s most directly comparable model, the 1003C:
– Epropulsion Spirit 1.0kW S (std shaft), 1018Wh battery, £1529
– Epropulsion Spirit 1.0kW XS (extra short shaft), 1018Wh battery, £1529
– Epropulsion Spirit 1.0kW L (long shaft), 1018Wh battery, £1575
– Epropulsion Spirit spare battery 1018Wh £899
– Epropulsion Spirit spare propeller £50
– Epropulsion 12V DC and solar control charger £89*
– Epropulsion Fast Mains Charger**, £250
– Epropulsion bag set(motor and battery) £149
* 12V Charger. Because of the voltage at which the Spirit battery needs to charge, this is actually quite a sophisticated DC-DC “step-up” charger and current controller, hence the additional cost compared to the Torqeedo 12V charging cable (which is effectively a piece of cable with the right connectors on both ends). This means the Epropulsion can also be connected directly to most solar panels, ie there is no need for any extra controllers or regulators in between, and you don’t have to use any particular make of solar panel.
** Fast Mains Charger. The price of both motors includes a standard mains charger but Epropulsion also offer a fast charger that reduces the charge time to 2.5 hrs from flat. As with all fast charging though, this benefit is not without cost. It does not “harm” the battery as such, but in terms of battery longevity is roughly equivalent to two cycles of charging at the standard speed.
CHOOSING & BUYING YOUR ELECTRIC OUTBOARD MOTOR
If you contact us you will be able to speak to somebody who has actually used both the ePropulsion and the Torqeedo on the water, and can give genuine, useful (realistic!) advice about battery life, range, and whether your particular boat is suited to electric drive.
As of August 2018 we are – to the best of our knowledge – the only UK Dealer to stock both makes. By that we don’t mean “we can get one if you really want us to”; we usually have both Torqeedo and Epropulsion motors available to see and buy. There are many similarities between the two, but also some important differences. We have seen and tried both, quite extensively, and it’s only by stocking both we believe we can listen to what you want and recommend the one that will suit you better (rather than being a single brand dealer and forced into trying to sell you that one…).
We must emphasise, we have nothing against the Torqeedo 1003 – we’ve been selling them for nearly ten years, they are very good motors – but we really do feel it’s in our customers’ interests to be able to compare Torqeedo and Epropulsion directly next to each other, rather than at separate dealers perhaps 50 miles apart. If you would like to compare the two motors for yourself, we have both here, please come and see us.
Send us a message online now
Mobile – 07768 600595
Tel – 0800 999 2535 (FREE from UK landlines)
Email – email@example.com